Root cause
Recovery challenge state did not maintain sufficiently strict binding among account, device context, and verification secret. Review challenge ownership and uniqueness throughout the recovery lifecycle.
Demonstrated impact
Researcher reports a separate, lower-severity account-takeover finding, fixed before publication.
What to check for
- Bind each recovery challenge to its intended account; a shared device context is not evidence of account ownership.
- Editorial review objective: use synthetic-account unit tests to verify that sharing a device context cannot make one account's recovery challenge authorize another account's recovery.
Award and evidence
How the award was verified, and what the record does not establish
Individual finding, distinct from the researcher’s other Instagram recovery report; no additional bonus is counted. The primary article states $10000 without naming the currency. USD is a contextual inference from source-3, Facebook’s official 2019 program retrospective published February 7, 2020, roughly six months after the August 25, 2019 original article publication. The retrospective reports program-wide amounts in USD; it does not independently establish the denomination or settlement of this individual award. Exact award/payment dates remain unknown.
- The current 2024 article header is not the original disclosure date
- Exact report, fix, and award dates are unavailable
- No independent vendor-hosted payout confirmation retrieved
- Current article update: 2024-12-06; original publication is stored separately.
- USD is inferred from later program-wide context (source-3), not explicitly stated by the individual award source; neither individual denomination nor cash settlement is independently confirmed.
Timeline
- Published
- 2019-08-25explicit · Original publication date preserved by the author’s archive; current article header is a later update.
Related cases
- Google device grants lost client and permission binding
Google · Authentication and identity · USD 13,337
- GitLab recovery delivery lacked verified-address binding
GitLab · Authentication and identity · USD 35,000
- LiteSpeed Cache privileged user simulation relied on weak security tokens
LiteSpeed Technologies · Authentication and identity · USD 14,400
- Meta Quest login migration lost OAuth credential confinement
Meta · Authentication and identity · USD 44,250
Sources
- Instagram recovery challenges were insufficiently bound to accountsLaxman Muthiyah · reviewed 2026-10-03
- Original publication archiveLaxman Muthiyah · reviewed 2026-10-02
- Facebook 2019 Bug Bounty retrospective — contextual USD denomination onlyDan Gurfinkel / Facebook · reviewed 2026-10-03
Record reviewed 2026-10-03. Snapshot af2809c308fc. Open the complete JSON contract.